WomensHealth
  • News
  • Health
  • Fitness
  • Sex & Love
  • Food
  • Lifestyle
  • Weight Loss
  • Women In Sport
  • Podcasts
  • Subscribe
  • Video
WomensHealth
  • News
  • Health
  • Fitness
  • Sex & Love
  • Food
  • Lifestyle
  • Weight Loss
  • Women In Sport
  • Podcasts
  • Subscribe
  • Video
This Simple, Effective Ab Workout Will Shred Your Six-Pack
Watch 0:23

This Simple, Effective Ab Workout Will Shred Your Six-Pack

{headline}

{headline}

Why We Need To Stop Thinking About Some Foods As Empty Calories

Why We Need To Stop Thinking About Some Foods As Empty Calories

‘By Combining Keto And Intermittent Fasting, I Finally Stopped Binge Eating And Lost 34kg’

‘By Combining Keto And Intermittent Fasting, I Finally Stopped Binge Eating And Lost 34kg’

Rebel Wilson Shared An Interesting Byproduct Of Her Weight Loss Journey

Rebel Wilson Shared An Interesting Byproduct Of Her Weight Loss Journey

'I Lost More Than 40kgs By Making These Small Changes To My Lifestyle'

'I Lost More Than 40kgs By Making These Small Changes To My Lifestyle'

{headline}

{headline}

Is It Healthy To Combine Intermittent Fasting With Keto?

Is It Healthy To Combine Intermittent Fasting With Keto?

This Meal Plan Is Trending On Social - Here’s What 3 Nutritionists Think

This Meal Plan Is Trending On Social - Here’s What 3 Nutritionists Think

‘I Lost 7kg of Fat on this Weight Lifting Program'

‘I Lost 7kg of Fat on this Weight Lifting Program'

{headline}

{headline}

How Much Weight Can You Safely Lose In Six Weeks?

How Much Weight Can You Safely Lose In Six Weeks?

Rebel Wilson Credits Her Weight Loss To The Mayr Method - But What Is That Exactly?

Rebel Wilson Credits Her Weight Loss To The Mayr Method - But What Is That Exactly?

4 Ways To Track Progress Without Using A Scale

4 Ways To Track Progress Without Using A Scale

This Is Likely The First Place You'll Notice Weight Loss

This Is Likely The First Place You'll Notice Weight Loss

This Is Exactly What Kourtney Kardashian Eats On The Keto Diet

This Is Exactly What Kourtney Kardashian Eats On The Keto Diet

Here's What A Day Of Eating On The Slow-Carb Diet Looks Like

Here's What A Day Of Eating On The Slow-Carb Diet Looks Like

13 Common Causes Of Sudden, Unexplained Weight Gain

13 Common Causes Of Sudden, Unexplained Weight Gain

  1. Home
  2. Weight Loss

This New Study Will Make You Question Everything You Know About The Fasting Diet Trend

The popular diet method isn't as it seems... - by Nina Bahadur
  • 03 May 2017
This New Study Will Make You Question Everything You Know About The Fasting Diet Trend

Ever heard of alternate-day fasting? It's a form of intermittent fasting that's becoming pretty popular as a weight-loss method.

Here's the idea: During your "fasting" days, you seriously restrict your calorie intake. But during "feast" days, you can go all out and eat whatever you like. But does this method actually work?

For a new study, researchers from the University of Illinois at Chicago divided 100 obese but metabolically healthy patients into three groups. During the first six months, one group tried alternate-day fasting (eating 25 percent of their calorie needs on fast days and 125 percent of their calories on feast days), the second group tried daily calorie restriction (consuming 75 percent of their calorie needs each day), and the third group, the control, had no intervention. During the last six months of the year-long study, the "weight maintenance" phase, the groups increased their calorie intake: The alternate-day fasting group consumed 50 percent of their calorie needs on fast days and 150 percent on feast days, and the calorie restriction group consumed 100 percent of their calorie needs each day.

RELATED: The Five-Day Diet Regime That Can Slash Kilos And Your Cancer Risk

A quick note on what those fast-day calorie restrictions actually were: During fast days, participants were expected to limit themselves to about 500 calories a day. Everyone's calorie requirements are different, depending on things like height, weight, activity level—the list goes on. But the Dietary Guidelines for Americans say young women should aim for 1,800 to 2,400 daily calories, according to the office of disease prevention and health promotion. So, 500 calories a day is seriously restrictive, and not necessarily recommended unless you are under the guidance of a professional (as was the case in this study).

The results, published in JAMA Internal Medicine, showed that after a full year there wasn't much difference between the groups. Basically, the researchers found that alternate-day fasting didn't produce superior weight loss, weight maintenance, adherence to the diet, or any improvement in risk indicators for heart disease when compared to those who just restricted their calories.

Yosub Kim, Content Strategy Director GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY

RELATED: 6 Expert-Approved Ways To Lose Fat Fast

Not surprisingly, the study had a lot of dropouts, too: 13 alternative-day fasting participants, 10 calorie restriction participants, and 8 control group participants left the trial before the end. And, as you might have guessed, multiple alternate-day fasting dropouts said the program was just too difficult to follow.

So, it sounds like alternate-day fasting is a pretty unpleasant experience, and it doesn't necessarily work. Which is fair since calorie counting doesn't work for everyone, and what happens to your body when you skip a meal isn't pretty. While no singular weight-loss method works for everyone, this particular diet sounds like a write-off—so feel free to pass on fasting.

This article originally appeared in Womenshealthmag.com

Subscribe Now-

Subscribe Now
Subscribe Now

Subscribe Now-

Subscribe Now
Subscribe Now

Recommended to you

This Simple, Effective Ab Workout Will Shred Your Six-Pack
Watch 0:23

This Simple, Effective Ab Workout Will Shred Your Six-Pack

{headline}

{headline}

Why We Need To Stop Thinking About Some Foods As Empty Calories

Why We Need To Stop Thinking About Some Foods As Empty Calories

‘By Combining Keto And Intermittent Fasting, I Finally Stopped Binge Eating And Lost 34kg’

‘By Combining Keto And Intermittent Fasting, I Finally Stopped Binge Eating And Lost 34kg’

Rebel Wilson Shared An Interesting Byproduct Of Her Weight Loss Journey

Rebel Wilson Shared An Interesting Byproduct Of Her Weight Loss Journey

'I Lost More Than 40kgs By Making These Small Changes To My Lifestyle'

'I Lost More Than 40kgs By Making These Small Changes To My Lifestyle'

{headline}

{headline}

Is It Healthy To Combine Intermittent Fasting With Keto?

Is It Healthy To Combine Intermittent Fasting With Keto?

This Meal Plan Is Trending On Social - Here’s What 3 Nutritionists Think

This Meal Plan Is Trending On Social - Here’s What 3 Nutritionists Think

‘I Lost 7kg of Fat on this Weight Lifting Program'

‘I Lost 7kg of Fat on this Weight Lifting Program'

{headline}

{headline}

How Much Weight Can You Safely Lose In Six Weeks?

How Much Weight Can You Safely Lose In Six Weeks?

Rebel Wilson Credits Her Weight Loss To The Mayr Method - But What Is That Exactly?

Rebel Wilson Credits Her Weight Loss To The Mayr Method - But What Is That Exactly?

4 Ways To Track Progress Without Using A Scale

4 Ways To Track Progress Without Using A Scale

This Is Likely The First Place You'll Notice Weight Loss

This Is Likely The First Place You'll Notice Weight Loss

This Is Exactly What Kourtney Kardashian Eats On The Keto Diet

This Is Exactly What Kourtney Kardashian Eats On The Keto Diet

Here's What A Day Of Eating On The Slow-Carb Diet Looks Like

Here's What A Day Of Eating On The Slow-Carb Diet Looks Like

13 Common Causes Of Sudden, Unexplained Weight Gain

13 Common Causes Of Sudden, Unexplained Weight Gain

WomensHealth
  • Contact Us
  • About Paragon Media
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Statement
  • Contact Paragon Media
  • Contact Us
  • About Paragon Media
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Statement
  • Contact Paragon Media

Brands

Our Network

  • Paragon Media Pty Ltd
  • Men’s Health
© 2021 Are Media PTY LTD
Get more from

Magazine Subscription Offer

Subscribe Now-

Shop This Offer
Subscribe Now