In Kim's Instagram with her sister, Kylie Jenner, both are wearing matching one-legged bodysuits. (Perhaps inspired by J.Lo's sparkly birthday suit?) Each sister has one leg exposed and one foot in a transparent sandal—with all five toes also visible. Except, if you look REALLY close at Kim's foot, there are six. (Believe me, I counted them twice.)
It's hard to see in the original image on Instagram unless you zoom in super close and take out your magnifying glass. But, once you see it, it's crystal clear. There are too many toes. Here's the original snap:
And, here it is with super-zoom.
Many of Kim's IG followers quickly commented on the pic, asking the reality TV star and makeup mogul the inevitable question: "Why you got 6 toes?" (Kim has yet to respond.)
Maybe it's not a photoshop fail, and Kim does have an extra piggy. If that's the case, she's not alone.
On a recent episode of Bachelor In Paradise (the US version, obvs) Demi Burnett found a footprint in the sand that had not five, but six toes. "Who is the monster running around here with six toes?" she asked when she discovered it. (Just ignore the fact that a producer probably pointed it out to her first, because who sits around counting toes in footprints in the sand?)
Everyone started freaking out about who could be the six-toed wonder on BiP. Demi thought the print was Blake Horstmann's, but changed her tune after Kim's photo debuted.
Consider this mystery solved.
This article originally appeared on Women's Health US.